By Kerr Fireplace | Trusted Across Kerrville, Fredericksburg, Boerne & Surrounding Areas
If you live in the Texas Hill Country and you’re thinking about installing a fireplace — or upgrading your current one — the first big decision is this: gas or wood?
While both gas and wood-burning fireplaces offer warmth, comfort, and that unmistakable ambiance, they differ in style, maintenance, efficiency, and lifestyle compatibility.
At Kerr Fireplace, we’ve helped homeowners across the Hill Country choose the perfect fireplace for their homes — whether it’s a rustic ranch in Ingram or a modern new build in Boerne. In this guide, we’ll walk you through the pros, cons, and real-world considerations of gas vs. wood-burning fireplaces — so you can make the right decision for your space.
Wood Fireplaces – Traditional Charm and Hands-On Experience
Wood-burning fireplaces are the classic choice. There’s something magical about the scent of real burning wood, the sound of crackling flames, and the cozy, off-grid independence that comes with it.
Pros of Wood Fireplaces:
- Authentic ambiance — nothing beats the smell, sound, and visual of a real fire.
- No electricity or gas required — ideal for rural properties or power outages.
- Works well with rustic or traditional design styles.
- Can be used with locally sourced wood, including mesquite, oak, and hickory.
Cons of Wood Fireplaces:
- Requires regular chimney sweeping to remove creosote buildup.
- Manual effort to build, manage, and clean after fires.
- Less efficient unless equipped with an EPA-certified insert.
- Not ideal for quick or spontaneous use — firebuilding takes time.
Best Use Cases for Wood Fireplaces in the Hill Country:
- Homes with rustic, farmhouse, or traditional interiors.
- Rural properties where natural fuel is abundant.
- Homeowners who enjoy the hands-on ritual of building a fire.
- Those who want a backup heat source not dependent on utilities.
Gas Fireplaces – Modern Convenience and Clean Operation
Gas fireplaces are the most popular choice among modern homeowners in Texas. They provide reliable warmth and ambiance at the push of a button, making them an ideal fit for today’s fast-paced lifestyle.
Pros of Gas Fireplaces:
- Instant ignition — just flip a switch or use a remote.
- No mess — no ash, smoke, or wood to store.
- Highly efficient — many units come with blowers or thermostatic controls.
- Ideal for families, seniors, or anyone who wants warmth without hassle.
Cons of Gas Fireplaces:
- Requires a gas line connection (installation may involve trenching).
- Slightly higher upfront cost for installation vs. basic wood models.
- While realistic, gas logs don’t replicate the full wood-burning experience.
Best Use Cases for Gas Fireplaces in the Hill Country:
- New builds or modern remodels seeking a clean, efficient heat source.
- Busy families who want quick and easy comfort.
- Aging homeowners or retirees wanting low-maintenance heating.
- Commercial properties (offices, hotels, restaurants) where safety and efficiency matter.
Thinking of Converting? Wood to Gas Is a Smart Move
Have an old wood-burning fireplace that you rarely use because it’s too much work? A gas log conversion might be the perfect solution.
Benefits of Converting:
- Keep the same firebox and chimney — just replace the logs and ignition.
- Add wall switch or remote operation.
- Eliminate wood hauling, ash removal, and soot stains.
- Improve indoor air quality and reduce smoke risk.
At Kerr Fireplace, we specialize in safe, certified gas log conversions across the Hill Country — and we’ll handle everything from inspection to gas line installation.
🔧 Efficiency Comparison
| Feature | Gas Fireplace | Wood Fireplace |
| Start-Up Time | Instant | 10–15 minutes |
| Heat Output Control | High (thermostat or blower) | Manual |
| Maintenance Needs | Low | High |
| Year-Round Use | Yes (if vent-free or electric ignition) | Seasonal |
| Backup Heat (off-grid) | No | Yes |
Gas fireplaces tend to win on efficiency and ease, while wood-burning units win on experience and independence.
Outdoor Fireplaces: The Best of Both Worlds
Don’t forget — Kerr Fireplace also installs outdoor fireplaces and fire pits, and both gas and wood work beautifully in backyard settings.
Outdoor Gas Fireplaces:
- Cleaner and more controlled.
- Easy to ignite and turn off (great for poolside or patio areas).
- Works well with modern landscaping.
Outdoor Wood Fireplaces:
- Rustic charm and traditional feel.
- Ideal for ranch-style backyards or large lots.
- Adds a natural touch to evening gatherings.
Whatever your style, our team can help you choose the right setup for your outdoor living space.
Design & Aesthetic Considerations
Choosing between gas and wood isn’t just about functionality — it’s also about how your fireplace looks and feels in your space.
Wood Fireplace Styles:
- Works well with limestone surrounds, reclaimed wood mantels, or brick hearths.
- A go-to for Hill Country-style homes, cabins, and older properties.
Gas Fireplace Styles:
- Clean lines and sleek finishes complement modern, transitional, or contemporary spaces.
- Linear gas fireplaces are popular in remodels and new builds.
Looking for something unique? Kerr Fireplace offers custom fireplace design to match your personal taste — whether it’s classic Texas or cutting-edge modern.
What About Venting?
Vent type matters, especially in Texas homes built for cooling more than heating.
Wood Fireplaces:
- Require a full masonry or prefabricated chimney.
- Need annual chimney cleaning and cap inspection.
Gas Fireplaces:
- Can be direct-vented, vent-free, or power-vented depending on model.
- Vent-free units are a good option for interior walls or rooms with limited access.
Kerr Fireplace will ensure your venting is up to code and works with your home’s layout, regardless of fireplace type.
⚙️ Maintenance Differences
| Task | Wood Fireplace | Gas Fireplace |
| Chimney Sweep | 1–2 times per year | Not needed (venting check only) |
| Ash Cleanup | Weekly in season | None |
| Glass Cleaning | Minimal | Occasional (soot buildup) |
| Pilot Light Check | N/A | Annually |
| Gasket / Seal Inspection | Occasionally | Annually |
In short, gas is easier to maintain, while wood requires more upkeep — but gives you that traditional fire-loving experience.
Why Work With Kerr Fireplace?
We don’t just install fireplaces — we help families and businesses create comfortable, safe, and beautiful living spaces across the Hill Country.
Why customers trust us:
- Over 20 years of fireplace experience
- Certified in gas, wood, and electric systems
- Locally owned and operated in Kerrville
- Trusted across Fredericksburg, Boerne, Bandera, and more
- Residential and commercial fireplace experts
- Specialists in custom fireplace design, installation, repair, and conversions
Whether you want a hands-off gas fireplace or the classic wood-burning experience, we’ll help you choose the right fit — and install it with craftsmanship and care.
Ready to Find the Right Fireplace for Your Home?
Still unsure which option is best for your home or lifestyle? Let us help. Our team offers free consultations to walk you through the process and show you the best gas or wood fireplace options for your space.
Call Kerr Fireplace or request a quote online today.
We’ll help you bring the warmth of the Texas Hill Country into your home — one perfect fireplace at a time.